Skip Navigation

New York Strip Steak

smoked paprika butter
4.4 stars
(865 reviews)
Available on 11/01/2018
  • Nut-Free
  • Egg-Free
Aspen Ridge Natural Beef New York Strip Steak. A bit of steak trivia for you. In 1837, Delmonico’s Restaurant opened in Manhattan. One of its signature dishes was a cut from the short loin that they named "The Delmonico". In homage to Manhattan, that same cut is today called a New York Strip Steak. We serve ours broiled, with grilled asparagus, smoked paprika butter and crispy shallots.
Ingredients

Paprika Butter (optional)
  • Butter
  • Salt
  • Black Pepper
Nutrition
Per Serving*
1.0 Per Container
With
Paprika Butter
Without
Paprika Butter
Calories 850 630
Total Fat 53g 28g
Saturated Fat 23g 8g
Trans Fat 0g 0g
Cholesterol 250mg 185mg
Sodium 1520mg 1470mg
Total Carbs 16g 16g
Dietary Fiber 6g 6g
Sugars 3g 3g
Protein 73g 73g
Vitamin A 2740IU 2739IU
Vitamin C 25mg 25mg
Calcium 106mg 105mg
Iron 6mg 6mg
*Our nutrition data includes all sauces, dressings, condiments, and garnishes included with a dish. If you have specific concerns about sodium, fat, or overall calories, know that we often serve these items on the side so you can add them to taste or leave them out, if you like.

What People Are Saying

3 Stars
Steak not worth the price.
3 Stars
Small for price. Not a great value. Maybe add a baked potato
3 Stars
Huge fatty bit no meat -never again
5 Stars
Incredibly high quality steak. The asparagus was roasted to perfection!
1 Stars
This was my first munchery meal and I am very disappointed. Steak was undercooked, bland and no directions included other than heat in ice. Garnish and sauce was included with no direction.
3 Stars
The butter didn’t pair well with the item. It gave it a funny taste
2 Stars
My Delivery was set for 5-6pm but my food came late at 6:35min, after which I had to heat up my food for another 20min. It was not a very pleasant experience as I was starving by the time I actually ate my food.
3 Stars
The asparagus was not cooked properly
1 Stars
Taste and texture was off didnt taste right
2 Stars
Very fat
2 Stars
The steak had a bit more fat than I liked, and the paprika butter was very bitter and not a good topping choice. Luckily, I tasted it before I added it to the cooked meal.
2 Stars
too expensive
5 Stars
Very tasty lovely shallots butter and lemon
3 Stars
Fatty
4 Stars
The steak was great. The asparagus w as shriveled and looked old. Not sure if microwave should be used to heat it. Otherwise good quality meat. Some sauce like horseradish or Bernice would have been nice. Not sure what the orange butter sauce was.
3 Stars
Over cooked
3 Stars
Very chewy for a New York
5 Stars
It looks like you did everything people mentioned, The asparagus wasn't overdone The pieces of New York with the larger not quite as Grizzley and the Paprika butter wasn't as salty!
5 Stars
Steak was succulent, asparagus was juicy and deep green and the smoked paprika butter was to-die-for delicious...mmm!
2 Stars
The steaks were poor. The grissle/fat-to-steak ratio was higher than it should have been and we ended-up hungry at the end, because we trimmed off so much. It was surprising coming from Munchery, because up until now, we have loved everything.
5 Stars
Perfectly cooked steak and asparagus! Just delicious! Will definitely order again!
4 Stars
Delicious but needs another side like potatoes.
5 Stars
This was probably the best meal that I've had from Munchery! The asparagus was a little overdone but I can live with that. it was perfect for reheating on the grill. More like that!
2 Stars
Gristly,tough meat
1 Stars
The asparagus was sandy.
2 Stars
The quality of beef has been really slacking lately. Lots of gristle and fat marbled throughout the cut. I had at least a fourth of the steak that was inedible because of all of the fat.
1 Stars
This was a very tough square of meat with an end of fat. Over cooked.
3 Stars
Could use something more than 4 pieces of asparagus and a steak for the money.
3 Stars
The meat was very tough
1 Stars
Half of the steak was filled with gristle...no exaggeration.
5 Stars
This was a really nice steak with asparagus. It didn't need the butter it came with. I found to be a bit salty. Potatoes would have been a nice addition.
3 Stars
The butter for the steak wasn't that great, recommend using either a peppercorn cream sauce or maybe a bourbon reduction
2 Stars
The taste was fine but that was one of the nastiest pieces of meat I've had. It's been a long time but now that I think about it I believe I stopped ordering from Munchery for many months because of a meat order I received. This steak was gristled, c
2 Stars
Poor cut of meat
5 Stars
Definitely one of my favorites!
4 Stars
Great flavors in the steak, which had two moderately large heels of fat. (Our asparagus was over cooked tonight)
3 Stars
Steak needed to be trimmed of some fat, increase asparagus portion
1 Stars
Very disappointing and over-priced. Steak was small, tough and about one-third was gristle, There were only four asparagus spears (much fewer than in photo) and they were gritty/sandy as though they had not been properly washed.
5 Stars
Yummy! Cooked perfectly.
5 Stars
Great
5 Stars
Healthy and tasty!
3 Stars
Nice fresh tasting steak, really good dish. But the second time I had this, the meat tasted tired ... so sadly I am lowering the stars.
3 Stars
Very fatty

Check Your Email

We just sent you an email. Follow the instructions to activate your account.

Log In To Your Account

OR